Open Mouth, Insert Stiletto
Received a phone call from JSquared last night and he had a "we have to talk" tone in his voice. He had just gotten off the phone with a friend of his, whose wedding we attended at the beginning of June. Groom was extremely angry with me and angry with JSquared for bringing me to the wedding.
Why you ask? At some point during the wedding, I remarked to the Groom’s brother, Super Sensitive Shorty (hereinafter "SSS"), something along the lines "Stand up straight. You look much taller with good posture." This incredibly upset SSS who, prior to my comment, was having a fantastic evening at his brother’s wedding. Apparently he had some growth issues as a child, spending six years in a brace and is extremely sensitive about his height (approximately 5'7"?). My comment sent SSS into a tailspin for the rest of the evening. This then upset Groom, who was angry that SSS was so upset. This in turn upset Bride, who was angry that Groom and SSS were so upset.
So Groom and Jsquared had a nice hour long row about me - "What kind of person makes a comment like that?" "Her drunkenness doesn’t excuse her comments." "Lux is the queen of evil." Etc. JSquared valiantly defended me, explaining that I HAD NO IDEA about his brother’s childhood height issues and that my comments were not meant to offend. Jsquared also explained that he knew I would feel horribly about this and would want to apologize in any way I could. By the end of the conversation Groom had calmed down somewhat and said he would speak to SSS and see how he wanted to proceed.
After hearing all of this, I felt lower than dirt. I couldn’t stop thinking about the awful ripple effect caused by my comments. I hurt SSS. By hurting him I hurt Groom and Bride. By hurting them I caused a rift between JSquared and Groom. If I had known about SSS’s childhood ailments, I never would have made those comments. I made a random insensitive comment that meant no harm, but through the intersection of circumstances caused a ton of damage. I am terribly sorry about all of this and I plan on doing whatever I can to make things right.
However, I do have a few thoughts:
1. I do not remember making these comments. I do not doubt that I said this or am trying to absolve myself of any blame. I note this only to show that these were surfacely innocuous comments and nothing about the conversation or SSS's response to my comments stand out in my mind.
2. What I said really wasn’t that offensive. Insensitive, yes. Offensive, no. And the comments came from a good place. Though this is only my opinion, I believe that a shorter person can look inches taller by having good posture and walking into a room as if he/she owns it. SSS is a nice, shy, sensitive guy, albeit with terrible posture. Now I know that SSS’s bad posture comes from genetics rather than old-fashioned slouching. And that his posture in general is none of my business. However, at the time, I just wanted to make SSS aware of what good posture combined with a composed bearing could do for him.
3. Why didn’t SSS say something to me right after I commented on his height? Why not say immediately afterwards "You know I had growth issues as a child and I don’t appreciate you commenting on my height." Or, when I ran into SSS a week later, why didn’t he say something to me then? Why is Groom fighting SSS’s battles? SSS is an adult in his late twenties, not a child. If SSS has a problem with me, why didn’t he speak up?
4. Does the phrase "mountain out of a molehill" occur to anyone? Or "big baby"?
5. In the law, there exists the concept of the "hypersensitive plaintiff." Basically, a defendant will not be held liable to a person who suffers severe emotional trauma from conduct that would not seriously harm most people. SSS, Groom, and Bride fail to recognize that my comments about SSS’s height and posture, though none of my business, would not seriously upset a person who did not have SSS’s childhood history. These comments especially wouldn’t send most people into an emotional nosedive, making them unable to enjoy their sibling’s wedding. SSS - Grow up.
6. Why wait almost a full month to discuss this with JSquared, and therefore, me? I know Bride and Groom were on their honeymoon, but why didn’t they call when they got back two weeks ago? Why didn’t SSS say something when he saw me a week later? See #3.
Having gotten all of that out of my system, I publicly apologize to SSS. My insensitive comments, in light of what I now know about your history, were incredibly hurtful, and I’m sorry. If I had an inkling that my off the cuff statement would cause you this pain, I never would have said anything. No matter what my intent was or how innoffenseive I view my words, I still cut you to the core and I wish I could take them back.
I also publicly apologize to Bride and Groom. I like and respect both you very much. Finding out that my actions put a damper on your wedding hurts me deeply. I never meant to do so. I am incredibly sorry.
Why you ask? At some point during the wedding, I remarked to the Groom’s brother, Super Sensitive Shorty (hereinafter "SSS"), something along the lines "Stand up straight. You look much taller with good posture." This incredibly upset SSS who, prior to my comment, was having a fantastic evening at his brother’s wedding. Apparently he had some growth issues as a child, spending six years in a brace and is extremely sensitive about his height (approximately 5'7"?). My comment sent SSS into a tailspin for the rest of the evening. This then upset Groom, who was angry that SSS was so upset. This in turn upset Bride, who was angry that Groom and SSS were so upset.
So Groom and Jsquared had a nice hour long row about me - "What kind of person makes a comment like that?" "Her drunkenness doesn’t excuse her comments." "Lux is the queen of evil." Etc. JSquared valiantly defended me, explaining that I HAD NO IDEA about his brother’s childhood height issues and that my comments were not meant to offend. Jsquared also explained that he knew I would feel horribly about this and would want to apologize in any way I could. By the end of the conversation Groom had calmed down somewhat and said he would speak to SSS and see how he wanted to proceed.
After hearing all of this, I felt lower than dirt. I couldn’t stop thinking about the awful ripple effect caused by my comments. I hurt SSS. By hurting him I hurt Groom and Bride. By hurting them I caused a rift between JSquared and Groom. If I had known about SSS’s childhood ailments, I never would have made those comments. I made a random insensitive comment that meant no harm, but through the intersection of circumstances caused a ton of damage. I am terribly sorry about all of this and I plan on doing whatever I can to make things right.
However, I do have a few thoughts:
1. I do not remember making these comments. I do not doubt that I said this or am trying to absolve myself of any blame. I note this only to show that these were surfacely innocuous comments and nothing about the conversation or SSS's response to my comments stand out in my mind.
2. What I said really wasn’t that offensive. Insensitive, yes. Offensive, no. And the comments came from a good place. Though this is only my opinion, I believe that a shorter person can look inches taller by having good posture and walking into a room as if he/she owns it. SSS is a nice, shy, sensitive guy, albeit with terrible posture. Now I know that SSS’s bad posture comes from genetics rather than old-fashioned slouching. And that his posture in general is none of my business. However, at the time, I just wanted to make SSS aware of what good posture combined with a composed bearing could do for him.
3. Why didn’t SSS say something to me right after I commented on his height? Why not say immediately afterwards "You know I had growth issues as a child and I don’t appreciate you commenting on my height." Or, when I ran into SSS a week later, why didn’t he say something to me then? Why is Groom fighting SSS’s battles? SSS is an adult in his late twenties, not a child. If SSS has a problem with me, why didn’t he speak up?
4. Does the phrase "mountain out of a molehill" occur to anyone? Or "big baby"?
5. In the law, there exists the concept of the "hypersensitive plaintiff." Basically, a defendant will not be held liable to a person who suffers severe emotional trauma from conduct that would not seriously harm most people. SSS, Groom, and Bride fail to recognize that my comments about SSS’s height and posture, though none of my business, would not seriously upset a person who did not have SSS’s childhood history. These comments especially wouldn’t send most people into an emotional nosedive, making them unable to enjoy their sibling’s wedding. SSS - Grow up.
6. Why wait almost a full month to discuss this with JSquared, and therefore, me? I know Bride and Groom were on their honeymoon, but why didn’t they call when they got back two weeks ago? Why didn’t SSS say something when he saw me a week later? See #3.
Having gotten all of that out of my system, I publicly apologize to SSS. My insensitive comments, in light of what I now know about your history, were incredibly hurtful, and I’m sorry. If I had an inkling that my off the cuff statement would cause you this pain, I never would have said anything. No matter what my intent was or how innoffenseive I view my words, I still cut you to the core and I wish I could take them back.
I also publicly apologize to Bride and Groom. I like and respect both you very much. Finding out that my actions put a damper on your wedding hurts me deeply. I never meant to do so. I am incredibly sorry.
